{"data":{"sci_version": "1.2", "schema": "https://corpus.bntrg.co.uk/sci/1.0/sci.schema.json", "id": "pmid:36429070", "kind": "science-record", "revision": 3, "content_hash": "sha256:08a05da7de3c69479f3c8f88ddc856b0e752e9ecd946f9544deaf06065d0b5fa", "created_at": "2026-11-01T19:00:54Z", "updated_at": "2026-11-01T22:08:10Z", "generator": {"name": "corpus-assay-engine", "run_id": "reading-sci-2026-11-01"}, "paper": {"state": "complete", "title": "Immune Checkpoint Inhibitor (ICI) Genes and Aging in Clear Cell Renal Cell Carcinoma (ccRCC): Clinical and Genomic Study.", "doi": "10.3390/cells11223641", "pmid": "36429070", "authors": ["Abdullah Al-Danakh", "Mohammed Safi", "Mohammed Alradhi", "Qiwei Chen", "Salem Baldi", "Xinqing Zhu", "Deyong Yang"], "journal": "Cells", "year": 2022, "abstract": "Background: It is anticipated that there will be a large rise in the number of tumor diagnoses and mortality in those aged 65 and older over the course of upcoming decades. Immune checkpoint inhibitors, often known as ICIs, boost immune system activity by selectively targeting ICI genes. On the other hand, old age may be connected with unfavorable results. Methods: The Cancer Genome Atlas (TCGA) provided gene expression data from ccRCC tissue and key clinical variables. ICI gene databases were applied and verified using the GEO database. Results: We identified 14 ICI genes as risk gene signatures among 528 ccRCC patients using univariate and multivariable cox hazard models, and the elderly group was linked with poor survival. Then, by utilizing a new nomogram method, the TNFSF15 gene and age predicting values were estimated at one, three, and five years (85%, 81%, and 81%), respectively, and our age-related risk score was significant even after multivariable analysis (HR = 1.518, p = 0.009, CI = 1.1102.076). TNFSF15 gene expression was lower in elderly ccRCC patients (p = 0.0001). A negative connection between age and the TNFSF15 gene expression was discovered by correlation analysis (p = 0.0001). The verification of the gene by utilizing GEO (GSE167093) with 604 patients was obtained as external validation that showed significant differences in the TNFSF15 gene between young and elderly patients (p = 0.007). Additionally, the protein-protein interactions of the TNFSF15 gene with other ICI genes and aging-related genes was determined. In addition, the TNFSF15 expression was significantly correlated with pathological stages (p = 0.018). Furthermore, it was discovered that the biological processes of senescence, cellular senescence, the immune system, and many immune cell infiltration and immune function types are all closely tied. Conclusions: Along with the risk score evaluation, the ICI gene TNFSF15 was identified as a tumor suppressor gene related to inequalities in age survival and is associated with pathological stages and different immunity statuses. The aging responses of ccRCC patients and related gene expression need further investigation in order to identify potential therapeutic targets.", "claims": [{"id": "claim-method", "statement": "We identified prognostic genes using the univariate Cox hazard analysis method. After that, by using the survival package in the R language program, we accomplished a multivariable Cox hazard model that unveiled a score signature.", "kind": "methodological", "target": null, "evidence": [{"asset": "source:pmid:36429070", "locator": "sections[7] \"2.5. Statistical Analysis\" paragraph 2", "quote": "We identified prognostic genes using the univariate Cox hazard analysis method. After that, by using the survival package in the R language program, we accomplished a multivariable Cox hazard model that unveiled a score signature."}], "state": "complete"}, {"id": "claim-data-access", "statement": "All data in this study are open for all without need for patient consent and no require access approval. It is available in the GDC portal repository (https://portal.gdc.cancer.gov/, accessed on 5 August 2022).", "kind": "methodological", "target": null, "evidence": [{"asset": "source:pmid:36429070", "locator": "sections[21] \"notes\" paragraph 1", "quote": "All data in this study are open for all without need for patient consent and no require access approval. It is available in the GDC portal repository (https://portal.gdc.cancer.gov/, accessed on 5 August 2022)."}], "state": "complete"}, {"id": "claim-target-result", "statement": "Using TCGA ccRCC data, univariate and multivariable Cox hazard models identified a 14-gene ICI risk signature associated with poor survival in elderly patients, with TNFSF15 expression lower in elderly patients.", "kind": "quantitative", "target": {"value": 0.0001, "unit": "p-value", "tolerance": null, "source": "TNFSF15 gene expression was lower in elderly ccRCC patients (p = 0.0001)."}, "evidence": [{"asset": "source:pmid:36429070", "locator": "sections[0] \"Abstract\" paragraph 1", "quote": "We identified 14 ICI genes as risk gene signatures among 528 ccRCC patients using univariate and multivariable cox hazard models, and the elderly group was linked with poor survival."}, {"asset": "source:pmid:36429070", "locator": "sections[0] \"Abstract\" paragraph 1", "quote": "TNFSF15 gene expression was lower in elderly ccRCC patients (p = 0.0001)."}], "state": "complete"}], "gaps": []}, "experiment": {"state": "complete", "objective": "Using TCGA ccRCC data, univariate and multivariable Cox hazard models identified a 14-gene ICI risk signature associated with poor survival in elderly patients, with TNFSF15 expression lower in elderly patients.", "steps": [{"id": "read_published_estimate", "order": 1, "name": "Read the published estimate from the source", "kind": "other", "state": "complete", "blocked_on": null, "description": "The claim, method and evidence span published with the source article.", "duration_hours": null, "parameters": {}, "inputs": ["source:pmid:36429070"], "outputs": ["the published estimate and its evidence"], "instruments": [], "reagents": []}, {"id": "obtain_source_data", "order": 2, "name": "Obtain the source data from the named repository", "kind": "data-preparation", "state": "complete", "blocked_on": null, "description": "The GEO series accession resolves and its sample accessions are listed. This lane did not download the dataset or read its licence.", "duration_hours": null, "parameters": {}, "inputs": ["data:geo:GSE167093"], "outputs": ["the source data with its repository provenance"], "instruments": [], "reagents": []}, {"id": "run_analysis", "order": 3, "name": "Run the published analysis", "kind": "analysis", "state": "complete", "blocked_on": null, "description": "Apply the paper's statistical method to the resolved series and compare the result with the published target.", "duration_hours": null, "parameters": {}, "inputs": ["data:geo:GSE167093"], "outputs": ["the replicated result and its comparison"], "instruments": [], "reagents": []}], "materials": [], "instruments": [], "reagents": [], "conditions": {}, "gaps": []}, "data": {"state": "partial", "assets": [{"id": "source:pmid:36429070", "role": "manuscript", "format": "xml", "media_type": "application/xml", "uri": "https://doi.org/10.3390/cells11223641", "sha256": "sha256:66db45ec825f155d39b4076e4ac1acd6ab4272e2dd24c3bab77429a1b4f12858", "bytes": 27812, "access": "open", "state": "resolved", "reader": null, "reader_status": "reader_required", "identifier": "10.3390/cells11223641", "version": null, "note": "Full article fetched from PMC; the checksum covers the rendered section body, not the original XML bytes.", "structure": {"pmcid": "PMC9688873", "source": "europe_pmc_fulltext", "coverage": "whole_body_without_references", "text_hash_scope": "rendered_section_body"}}, {"id": "data:geo:GSE167093", "role": "raw", "format": "geo-series", "media_type": "application/vnd.ncbi.geo-series+json", "uri": "https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/geo/query/acc.cgi?acc=GSE167093", "sha256": null, "bytes": null, "access": "open", "state": "resolved", "reader": null, "reader_status": "reader_required", "identifier": "GSE167093", "version": null, "note": "All data in this study are open for all without need for patient consent and no require access approval. It is available in the GDC portal repository (https://portal.gdc.cancer.gov/, accessed on 5 August 2022).", "structure": {"repository": "GEO", "access_route": "GEO accession URL", "access_statement_verbatim": "All data in this study are open for all without need for patient consent and no require access approval. It is available in the GDC portal repository (https://portal.gdc.cancer.gov/, accessed on 5 August 2022).", "access_statement_kind": "data_availability_statement", "sample_accessions": ["GSM5092664", "GSM5092665", "GSM5092666", "GSM5092667", "GSM5092668", "GSM5092669", "GSM5092670", "GSM5092671", "GSM5092672", "GSM5092673", "GSM5092674", "GSM5092675", "GSM5092676", "GSM5092677", "GSM5092678", "GSM5092679", "GSM5092680", "GSM5092681", "GSM5092682", "GSM5092683", "GSM5092684", "GSM5092685", "GSM5092686", "GSM5092687", "GSM5092688", "GSM5092689", "GSM5092690", "GSM5092691", "GSM5092692", "GSM5092693", "GSM5092694", "GSM5092695", "GSM5092696", "GSM5092697", "GSM5092698", "GSM5092699", "GSM5092700", "GSM5092701", "GSM5092702", "GSM5092703", "GSM5092704", "GSM5092705", "GSM5092706", "GSM5092707", "GSM5092708", "GSM5092709", "GSM5092710", "GSM5092711", "GSM5092712", "GSM5092713", "GSM5092714", "GSM5092715", "GSM5092716", "GSM5092717", "GSM5092718", "GSM5092719", "GSM5092720", "GSM5092721", "GSM5092722", "GSM5092723", "GSM5092724", "GSM5092725", "GSM5092726", "GSM5092727", "GSM5092728", "GSM5092729", "GSM5092730", "GSM5092731", "GSM5092732", "GSM5092733", "GSM5092734", "GSM5092735", "GSM5092736", "GSM5092737", "GSM5092738", "GSM5092739", "GSM5092740", "GSM5092741", "GSM5092742", "GSM5092743", "GSM5092744", "GSM5092745", "GSM5092746", "GSM5092747", "GSM5092748", "GSM5092749", "GSM5092750", "GSM5092751", "GSM5092752", "GSM5092753", "GSM5092754", "GSM5092755", "GSM5092756", "GSM5092757", "GSM5092758", "GSM5092759", "GSM5092760", "GSM5092761", "GSM5092762", "GSM5092763", "GSM5092764", "GSM5092765", "GSM5092766", "GSM5092767", "GSM5092768", "GSM5092769", "GSM5092770", "GSM5092771", "GSM5092772", "GSM5092773", "GSM5092774", "GSM5092775", "GSM5092776", "GSM5092777", "GSM5092778", "GSM5092779", "GSM5092780", "GSM5092781", "GSM5092782", "GSM5092783", "GSM5092784", "GSM5092785", "GSM5092786", "GSM5092787", "GSM5092788", "GSM5092789", "GSM5092790", "GSM5092791", "GSM5092792", "GSM5092793", "GSM5092794", "GSM5092795", "GSM5092796", "GSM5092797", "GSM5092798", "GSM5092799", "GSM5092800", "GSM5092801", "GSM5092802", "GSM5092803", "GSM5092804", "GSM5092805", "GSM5092806", "GSM5092807", "GSM5092808", "GSM5092809", "GSM5092810", "GSM5092811", "GSM5092812", "GSM5092813", "GSM5092814", "GSM5092815", "GSM5092816", "GSM5092817", "GSM5092818", "GSM5092819", "GSM5092820", "GSM5092821", "GSM5092822", "GSM5092823", "GSM5092824", "GSM5092825", "GSM5092826", "GSM5092827", "GSM5092828", "GSM5092829", "GSM5092830", "GSM5092831", "GSM5092832", "GSM5092833", "GSM5092834", "GSM5092835", "GSM5092836", "GSM5092837", "GSM5092838", "GSM5092839", "GSM5092840", "GSM5092841", "GSM5092842", "GSM5092843", "GSM5092844", "GSM5092845", "GSM5092846", "GSM5092847", "GSM5092848", "GSM5092849", "GSM5092850", "GSM5092851", "GSM5092852", "GSM5092853", "GSM5092854", "GSM5092855", "GSM5092856", "GSM5092857", "GSM5092858", "GSM5092859", "GSM5092860", "GSM5092861", "GSM5092862", "GSM5092863", "GSM5092864", "GSM5092865", "GSM5092866", "GSM5092867", "GSM5092868", "GSM5092869", "GSM5092870", "GSM5092871", "GSM5092872", "GSM5092873", "GSM5092874", "GSM5092875", "GSM5092876", "GSM5092877", "GSM5092878", "GSM5092879", "GSM5092880", "GSM5092881", "GSM5092882", "GSM5092883", "GSM5092884", "GSM5092885", "GSM5092886", "GSM5092887", "GSM5092888", "GSM5092889", "GSM5092890", "GSM5092891", "GSM5092892", "GSM5092893", "GSM5092894", "GSM5092895", "GSM5092896", "GSM5092897", "GSM5092898", "GSM5092899", "GSM5092900", "GSM5092901", "GSM5092902", "GSM5092903", "GSM5092904", "GSM5092905", "GSM5092906", "GSM5092907", "GSM5092908", "GSM5092909", "GSM5092910", "GSM5092911", "GSM5092912", "GSM5092913", "GSM5092914", "GSM5092915", "GSM5092916", "GSM5092917", "GSM5092918", "GSM5092919", "GSM5092920", "GSM5092921", "GSM5092922", "GSM5092923", "GSM5092924", "GSM5092925", "GSM5092926", "GSM5092927", "GSM5092928", "GSM5092929", "GSM5092930", "GSM5092931", "GSM5092932", "GSM5092933", "GSM5092934", "GSM5092935", "GSM5092936", "GSM5092937", "GSM5092938", "GSM5092939", "GSM5092940", "GSM5092941", "GSM5092942", "GSM5092943", "GSM5092944", "GSM5092945", "GSM5092946", "GSM5092947", "GSM5092948", "GSM5092949", "GSM5092950", "GSM5092951", "GSM5092952", "GSM5092953", "GSM5092954", "GSM5092955", "GSM5092956", "GSM5092957", "GSM5092958", "GSM5092959", "GSM5092960", "GSM5092961", "GSM5092962", "GSM5092963", "GSM5092964", "GSM5092965", "GSM5092966", "GSM5092967", "GSM5092968", "GSM5092969", "GSM5092970", "GSM5092971", "GSM5092972", "GSM5092973", "GSM5092974", "GSM5092975", "GSM5092976", "GSM5092977", "GSM5092978", "GSM5092979", "GSM5092980", "GSM5092981", "GSM5092982", "GSM5092983", "GSM5092984", "GSM5092985", "GSM5092986", "GSM5092987", "GSM5092988", "GSM5092989", "GSM5092990", "GSM5092991", "GSM5092992", "GSM5092993", "GSM5092994", "GSM5092995", "GSM5092996", "GSM5092997", "GSM5092998", "GSM5092999", "GSM5093000", "GSM5093001", "GSM5093002", "GSM5093003", "GSM5093004", "GSM5093005", "GSM5093006", "GSM5093007", "GSM5093008", "GSM5093009", "GSM5093010", "GSM5093011", "GSM5093012", "GSM5093013", "GSM5093014", "GSM5093015", "GSM5093016", "GSM5093017", "GSM5093018", "GSM5093019", "GSM5093020", "GSM5093021", "GSM5093022", "GSM5093023", "GSM5093024", "GSM5093025", "GSM5093026", "GSM5093027", "GSM5093028", "GSM5093029", "GSM5093030", "GSM5093031", "GSM5093032", "GSM5093033", "GSM5093034", "GSM5093035", "GSM5093036", "GSM5093037", "GSM5093038", "GSM5093039", "GSM5093040", "GSM5093041", "GSM5093042", "GSM5093043", "GSM5093044", "GSM5093045", "GSM5093046", "GSM5093047", "GSM5093048", "GSM5093049", "GSM5093050", "GSM5093051", "GSM5093052", "GSM5093053", "GSM5093054", "GSM5093055", "GSM5093056", "GSM5093057", "GSM5093058", "GSM5093059", "GSM5093060", "GSM5093061", "GSM5093062", "GSM5093063", "GSM5093064", "GSM5093065", "GSM5093066", "GSM5093067", "GSM5093068", "GSM5093069", "GSM5093070", "GSM5093071", "GSM5093072", "GSM5093073", "GSM5093074", "GSM5093075", "GSM5093076", "GSM5093077", "GSM5093078", "GSM5093079", "GSM5093080", "GSM5093081", "GSM5093082", "GSM5093083", "GSM5093084", "GSM5093085", "GSM5093086", "GSM5093087", "GSM5093088", "GSM5093089", "GSM5093090", "GSM5093091", "GSM5093092", "GSM5093093", "GSM5093094", "GSM5093095", "GSM5093096", "GSM5093097", "GSM5093098", "GSM5093099", "GSM5093100", "GSM5093101", "GSM5093102", "GSM5093103", "GSM5093104", "GSM5093105", "GSM5093106", "GSM5093107", "GSM5093108", "GSM5093109", "GSM5093110", "GSM5093111", "GSM5093112", "GSM5093113", "GSM5093114", "GSM5093115", "GSM5093116", "GSM5093117", "GSM5093118", "GSM5093119", "GSM5093120", "GSM5093121", "GSM5093122", "GSM5093123", "GSM5093124", "GSM5093125", "GSM5093126", "GSM5093127", "GSM5093128", "GSM5093129", "GSM5093130", "GSM5093131", "GSM5093132", "GSM5093133", "GSM5093134", "GSM5093135", "GSM5093136", "GSM5093137", "GSM5093138", "GSM5093139", "GSM5093140", "GSM5093141", "GSM5093142", "GSM5093143", "GSM5093144", "GSM5093145", "GSM5093146", "GSM5093147", "GSM5093148", "GSM5093149", "GSM5093150", "GSM5093151", "GSM5093152", "GSM5093153", "GSM5093154", "GSM5093155", "GSM5093156", "GSM5093157", "GSM5093158", "GSM5093159", "GSM5093160", "GSM5093161", "GSM5093162", "GSM5093163", "GSM5093164", "GSM5093165", "GSM5093166", "GSM5093167", "GSM5093168", "GSM5093169", "GSM5093170", "GSM5093171", "GSM5093172", "GSM5093173", "GSM5093174", "GSM5093175", "GSM5093176", "GSM5093177", "GSM5093178", "GSM5093179", "GSM5093180", "GSM5093181", "GSM5093182", "GSM5093183", "GSM5093184", "GSM5093185", "GSM5093186", "GSM5093187", "GSM5093188", "GSM5093189", "GSM5093190", "GSM5093191", "GSM5093192", "GSM5093193", "GSM5093194", "GSM5093195", "GSM5093196", "GSM5093197", "GSM5093198", "GSM5093199", "GSM5093200", "GSM5093201", "GSM5093202", "GSM5093203", "GSM5093204", "GSM5093205", "GSM5093206", "GSM5093207", "GSM5093208", "GSM5093209", "GSM5093210", "GSM5093211", "GSM5093212", "GSM5093213", "GSM5093214", "GSM5093215", "GSM5093216", "GSM5093217", "GSM5093218", "GSM5093219", "GSM5093220", "GSM5093221", "GSM5093222", "GSM5093223", "GSM5093224", "GSM5093225", "GSM5093226", "GSM5093227", "GSM5093228", "GSM5093229", "GSM5093230", "GSM5093231", "GSM5093232", "GSM5093233", "GSM5093234", "GSM5093235", "GSM5093236", "GSM5093237", "GSM5093238", "GSM5093239", "GSM5093240", "GSM5093241", "GSM5093242", "GSM5093243", "GSM5093244", "GSM5093245", "GSM5093246", "GSM5093247", "GSM5093248", "GSM5093249", "GSM5093250", "GSM5093251", "GSM5093252", "GSM5093253", "GSM5093254", "GSM5093255", "GSM5093256", "GSM5093257", "GSM5093258", "GSM5093259", "GSM5093260", "GSM5093261", "GSM5093262", "GSM5093263", "GSM5093264", "GSM5093265", "GSM5093266", "GSM5093267", "GSM5093268", "GSM5093269", "GSM5093270", "GSM5093271", "GSM5093272", "GSM5093273", "GSM5093274", "GSM5093275", "GSM5093276", "GSM5093277", "GSM5093278", "GSM5093279", "GSM5093280", "GSM5093281", "GSM5093282", "GSM5093283", "GSM5093284", "GSM5093285", "GSM5093286", "GSM5093287", "GSM5093288", "GSM5093289", "GSM5093290", "GSM5093291", "GSM5093292", "GSM5093293", "GSM5093294", "GSM5093295", "GSM5093296", "GSM5093297", "GSM5093298", "GSM5093299", "GSM5093300", "GSM5093301", "GSM5093302", "GSM5093303", "GSM5093304", "GSM5093305", "GSM5093306", "GSM5093307", "GSM5093308", "GSM5093309", "GSM5093310", "GSM5093311", "GSM5093312", "GSM5093313", "GSM5093314", "GSM5093315", "GSM5093316", "GSM5093317", "GSM5093318", "GSM5093319"], "sample_count": 656, "group_sizes": null, "group_sizes_basis": null, "platform": "10558", "taxon": "Homo sapiens", "title": "Sexual dimorphism in cancer: insights from transcriptional signatures in kidney tissues and renal cell carcinoma", "resolution_checked_at": "2026-11-01T17:30:42Z", "resolution_check": "identifier_resolution_only_no_download_no_licence_read", "downloaded": false, "licence_read": false}}], "gaps": ["asset:data:geo:GSE167093 not downloaded", "asset:data:geo:GSE167093 licence not read"]}, "analysis": {"state": "partial", "methods": [{"id": "method-1", "family": "group_comparison", "specific": "anova", "label": "Group comparison", "dsl_operations": ["group_summary", "welch_t", "bootstrap_mean_difference", "group_comparison_anova"], "missing_operations": [], "expressible": true, "parameters": {}, "data_shapes": ["two_or_more_groups_continuous"], "evidence": {"score": 0.8, "band": "high", "quote": "ANOVA"}}, {"id": "method-2", "family": "contingency_analysis", "specific": "chi_square", "label": "Categorical (contingency table) analysis", "dsl_operations": ["chi_square_test"], "missing_operations": [], "expressible": true, "parameters": {}, "data_shapes": ["categorical_cross_tabulation"], "evidence": {"score": 0.8, "band": "high", "quote": "Chi square"}}, {"id": "method-3", "family": null, "specific": null, "label": "univariate and multivariable Cox hazard models", "dsl_operations": [], "missing_operations": [], "expressible": null, "parameters": {}, "data_shapes": [], "evidence": {"score": 1.0, "band": "verbatim", "quote": "We identified prognostic genes using the univariate Cox hazard analysis method. After that, by using the survival package in the R language program, we accomplished a multivariable Cox hazard model that unveiled a score signature."}}], "targets": [{"id": "target-published-estimate", "claim_id": "claim-target-result", "operation": "bootstrap_mean_difference", "expected_value": 0.0001, "unit": "p-value", "tolerance": null, "state": "complete", "note": "The threshold the paper applied to its own result, as the paper states it. A run that reproduces the effect is judged against this threshold."}], "gaps": ["method.reader_named_unmapped"]}, "capability": {"state": "complete", "requirements": [{"capability_id": "capability:computational_analysis", "label": "Computational analysis platform", "assay_families": ["meta_analysis", "machine_learning", "survival_analysis", "statistical_regression", "pca", "molecular_docking", "network_analysis", "differential_expression", "gwas"], "availability_state": "owned", "tier_unlocked": "R1", "candidate": "Automated Assays Laravel application and simulated adapters"}], "gaps": []}, "readiness": {"state": "complete", "tier": "R1", "blocking_axis": "none", "blocked_on": "nothing:replicable_now", "axes": {"method": {"tier": "R1", "expressible": true, "required_operations": ["group_summary", "welch_t", "bootstrap_mean_difference", "group_comparison_anova"], "missing_operations": [], "basis": "The paper names the method it used and the corpus's method extractor maps it onto the DSL catalogue: anova."}, "capability": {"tier": "R1", "capability_id": "capability:computational_analysis", "availability_state": "owned", "basis": "The computational analysis is owned. The physical bench the paper used is not, so a physical validation cannot be run here."}, "data": {"tier": "R1", "reachable": true, "accessions": ["GSE167093"], "resolved_accessions": ["GSE167093"], "statements": ["All data in this study are open for all without need for patient consent and no require access approval. It is available in the GDC portal repository (https://portal.gdc.cancer.gov/, accessed on 5 August 2022)."], "basis": "The paper names GSE167093 in GEO and the accession resolves in the repository. No dataset was downloaded and no licence was read."}}, "can_run": {"dsl_operations": ["group_summary", "welch_t", "bootstrap_mean_difference", "group_comparison_anova"], "assets": ["source:pmid:36429070", "data:geo:GSE167093"], "steps": ["run_analysis"]}, "must_build": {"dsl_operations": [], "converters": [], "readers": [], "capabilities": [], "data_gaps": ["data:geo:GSE167093"]}, "gaps": []}, "review": {"state": "partial", "machine_critique": {"kind": "extraction_review", "reader": {"model": "MiniMax-M3.1-Flash", "provider": "minimax", "provider_family": "minimax", "read_at": "2026-11-01T18:16:52Z", "independence": "single_reader"}, "evidence_check": {"method": "verbatim", "availability": "verbatim"}, "calls": 5, "usage": {"prompt_tokens": 8568, "completion_tokens": 1682, "cached_tokens": 256}}, "human_critique": null, "stages": [{"id": "extraction", "state": "complete", "reader": "MiniMax-M3.1-Flash", "provider": "minimax"}], "gaps": ["review.independent_reader", "review.machine_critique", "review.human_critique"]}, "execution": {"state": "absent", "status": "not_run", "mode": null, "runs": [], "gaps": ["execution.not_run"]}, "provenance": {"entities": [{"id": "pmid:36429070", "type": "paper", "label": "pmid:36429070"}, {"id": "source:pmid:36429070", "type": "manuscript", "label": "PMID 36429070 full text"}, {"id": "data:geo:GSE167093", "type": "dataset", "label": "GEO GSE167093"}], "activities": [{"id": "activity-reading-sci-2026-11-01", "type": "classification", "used": [{"id": "pmid:36429070", "type": "paper", "label": "pmid:36429070"}, {"id": "source:pmid:36429070", "type": "manuscript", "label": "PMID 36429070 full text"}, {"id": "data:geo:GSE167093", "type": "dataset", "label": "GEO GSE167093"}], "agent": "agent:corpus-assay-engine"}, {"id": "activity-read-36429070", "type": "extraction", "used": ["source:pmid:36429070"], "agent": "agent:minimax-reader"}, {"id": "activity-resolve-GSE167093", "type": "accession_resolution", "used": ["data:geo:GSE167093"], "agent": "agent:corpus-assay-engine"}], "agents": [{"id": "agent:corpus-assay-engine", "type": "software", "label": "Corpus assay engine"}, {"id": "agent:minimax-reader", "type": "software", "label": "MiniMax literature reader"}], "source_run_id": "reading-sci-2026-11-01", "dsl_catalogue_fingerprint": "343fb30756ba6ec3", "capability_table_fingerprint": "2cb3e42f047d2ecf", "snapshot_id": "ba34b49490d9bfaf"}, "lineage": {"parent_id": "pmid:36429070", "parent_hash": "sha256:8fba4c32d6bd0dc82abbaae2bed8ddf1d21318829b94b4cad3d4885dacd60bb9", "fork_of": null, "generation": 2}, "gaps": ["asset:data:geo:GSE167093 licence not read", "asset:data:geo:GSE167093 not downloaded", "execution.not_run", "method.reader_named_unmapped", "review.human_critique", "review.independent_reader", "review.machine_critique"], "assays": [{"role": "analysis", "definition_id": "group_comparison", "definition_version": "f2132e96ae6c7a4e", "definition_digest": null, "required_operations": ["group_summary", "welch_t", "bootstrap_mean_difference", "group_comparison_anova"], "support_state": "supported", "source_hashes": {"dsl_catalogue": "f2132e96ae6c7a4e"}, "confidence": 0.8, "evidence": ["ANOVA"], "order_basis": "analysis_only", "id": "assay:1"}]},"meta":{"api_version":"v1","automation_ladder_snapshot":"ba34b49490d9bfaf","automation_ladder_caveats":["Method extraction is rule-based and has no hand-judged accuracy sample. Evidence bands order textual support; method agreement intervals are null (n=0), never probabilities. Work-type validation does not validate methods.","Operation coverage describes only explicitly named methods. It does not prove a complete protocol, compatible parameters, successful compilation or re-execution. Unrecognised or ambiguous methods require review.","Data reachability is a textual accession or public-data statement. No dataset was downloaded or checked for access, completeness or licence.","Capabilities are planning states seeded from the dated equipment register. No bench ownership, completed quote or partner booking is inferred. Procurement counts are dependencies, not guaranteed replications or financial returns.","Tier and blocker counts are deterministic assessments of this corpus, not measured agreement. R3 is reserved for procurement; unresolved methods and data require human work (R4). The most restrictive axis wins, with capability, method, data as tie-breaks. Resolving one blocker can leave another at the same tier."],"engine":"corpus_engine","engine_provider":"rule_based_v1+lex99e1195c7d6f","run_id":"run-20261023T122449232913","source":"esearch","source_detail":"PubMed mirror biomed_pubmed (read-only)","run_status":"complete","imported_at":"2026-11-03T20:16:52+00:00","generated_at":"2026-11-04T01:42:30+00:00","total_papers":5529,"total_assays_tracked":29,"automatable_assay_families":6,"validated":true,"caveat_count":9,"blocking_caveats":5,"caveats":[{"code":"low_evidence_dominates","basis":["4,152 of 5,529 classifications (75.1%) matched no cue evidence and sit at the 0.05 floor.","34 of 230 data_only calls (14.8%) are in that group."],"claim":"Work type and confidence bands","gloss":"Most records were classified from their title and framing alone, with assay-cue coverage at zero.","detail":"Most classifications in this run rest on no matched evidence at all. At the evidence floor the work type comes from title framing and a fixed prior, not from anything in the paper, so the published work-type split should be read as a rough triage signal rather than a measured distribution. The impact is bounded but not removed: since 2026-10-23 the engine excludes floor-confidence records from the shortlist entirely and publishes them separately as held out, so the recommendation is unaffected even though the census is.","status":"unverified","severity":"high"},{"code":"runtime_is_modelled","basis":["Runtime is summed from published per-assay hour figures. Timing awaits the first executed replication.","4,407 of 5,529 records (79.7%) model to 0.00 hours because no assay was matched, which the ranking then reads as \"cheapest\".","0 of 10 shortlisted records carry a 0.00-hour estimate."],"claim":"Estimated replication runtime","gloss":"The hour figures are estimates built from assay mentions; timing awaits the first executed replication.","detail":"The hour figures are a cost model derived from the bench steps implied by each matched assay family. The first executed replication will supply measured timing. Records without an assay match currently receive a zero-hour model value.","status":"unverified","severity":"high"},{"code":"signal_score_without_citations","basis":["5,529 of 5,529 records (100.0%) have no citation count from the source metadata."],"claim":"Signal score","gloss":"The signal score uses publication-type weight because the mirror supplied zero citation counts.","detail":"The source supplied no citation counts for any record in this run, so the signal score is publication-type weight only. The citation term of the ranking is inert here, and the shortlist is ordered by publication type alone.","status":"unverified","severity":"high"},{"code":"abstract_absent","basis":["1,667 of 5,529 records (30.2%) carry no abstract at all."],"claim":"Evidence base for classification","gloss":"Some records contain a title and publication type only, defining the available classification evidence.","detail":"Where the mirror contains a title and publication types only, those fields define the classifier evidence. A methods section is required for fuller automated and human review.","status":"unverified","severity":"medium"},{"code":"classifier_agreement_measured","basis":["Published two-way decision agreement 77.7% (310 of 399 decidable records) from a stratified hand-check of 438 real records.","Three-way diagnostic agreement 73.9% (288 of 390 decidable records).","data_only agreement 75.2% (100 of 133 decidable).","48 record(s) could not be decided from title and abstract and were excluded from the denominator.","56 analysis-only records were published under another work type, so the data_only share is not an upper bound."],"claim":"Published automatable decision","gloss":"This figure has been checked against a human reading the same papers, so we know how often it is right.","detail":"The published automatable / not-automatable distribution comes from a rule-based classifier that was hand-checked against a fixed ground-truth definition. The agreement rates below are measured, not estimated. The three-way work type remains a diagnostic and is reported separately.","status":"measured","severity":"high"},{"code":"llm_comparison_not_measured","basis":["rule_based_v1+lex99e1195c7d6f produced 5,529 of 5,529 classifications.","Measured on 438 labelled records; these are RULE-BASED figures, not model results."],"claim":"Rule-based versus LLM agreement","gloss":"Every number here is the rule engine’s own. Model comparison begins when a working API credential is connected and measured.","detail":"The published two-way decision agreed with a human reading on 310 of 399 decidable records (77.7%). The diagnostic three-way label agreed on 288 of 390 decidable records (73.9%). Every percentage in this run belongs to the rule engine. Model comparison begins when a working API credential is connected and measured.","status":"not_measured","severity":"high"},{"code":"confidence_is_a_band","basis":["low band: 135 of 210 hand-judged records were correct, 64.3% [57.6, 70.5] (95% CI).","medium band: 80 of 104 hand-judged records were correct, 76.9% [68.0, 84.0] (95% CI).","high band: 73 of 76 hand-judged records were correct, 96.0% [89.0, 98.7] (95% CI).","A fitted calibrated probability was built, measured and withdrawn: it overstated held-out accuracy and reorders nothing."],"claim":"Confidence band and evidence score","gloss":"The confidence band carries a measured accuracy interval; 0.85 represents relative rank strength.","detail":"Confidence on this run is a BAND plus its measured accuracy interval. The number stored alongside each record is a monotone evidence score that orders records; 0.85 represents relative rank strength. A fitted probability was withdrawn after it overstated held-out accuracy. Threshold on the band.","status":"measured","severity":"medium"},{"code":"three_way_split_is_diagnostic","basis":["The corpus is published at the two-way decision: automatable or not-automatable. The three-way split (data_only / physical / mixed) is published as a diagnostic with its measured reliability attached, not as a claim, because the rule engine's `mixed` call cannot be defended.","The engine called 22 record(s) mixed; 10 matched the human judgement (45.5%, 95% CI 26.9-65.3).","The engine's `mixed` call is right on 10/22 hand-judged records (45.5%, 95% CI 26.9%-65.3%); a constant `physical` guess scores 36.4%.","The engine's `mixed` call does not reliably beat a constant `physical` guess on the hand-judged records it labels mixed.","The sign of that difference flips between two independent samples, so the three-way refinement is not demonstrably informative.","The mixed stratum contributes a disproportionate share of errors relative to its size.","At title-only depth the physical/mixed split collapses: a title says that work was done, not whether it was also analysed."],"claim":"The published decision is two-way","gloss":"The three-way split is shown for diagnosis only. The published split is two ways.","detail":"Count and filter the corpus on automatable versus not-automatable. The data_only / physical / mixed split remains an internal engine diagnostic because the mixed call has lower measured reliability.","status":"measured","severity":"medium"},{"code":"automatable_flag_unproven","basis":["6 of 29 assay families are marked automatable now: meta_analysis, machine_learning, survival_analysis, pca, molecular_docking, differential_expression.","The flag is a rule over assay family and work type; validation begins with the first executed replication.","It inherits the 75.2% data_only agreement rate, because the flag requires the record to be analysis-only."],"claim":"Automatable now","gloss":"This flag marks assay families the rules classify as data-only. The first executed replication will validate it.","detail":"This flag marks families the rules consider replicable from data alone. Its validity depends on the analysis-only classification and will be measured through an executed replication.","status":"unverified","severity":"medium"}],"confidence_policy":"band_with_measured_interval","confidence_contract":{"policy":"band_with_measured_interval","summary":"Confidence is reported as a BAND with a measured accuracy interval. The raw evidence score supplies monotone ordering. A fitted point estimate was withdrawn after it overstated held-out accuracy.","evidence_score":"A monotone evidence score in [0,1] built from cue mass, axis separation and text coverage. Use it to order records. Interpret 0.85 as relative rank strength.","confidence_band":"low | medium | high. Consumers threshold on this value.","band_accuracy":"Wilson 95% interval on the measured agreement of the hand-judged records in this band.","calibrated_confidence":"WITHDRAWN. Reintroduction requires held-out evidence demonstrating reliable estimates across every bin."},"band_accuracy":{"low":{"n":210,"low":0.576,"band":"low","high":0.7046,"agree":135,"accuracy":0.6429},"high":{"n":76,"low":0.8903,"band":"high","high":0.9865,"agree":73,"accuracy":0.9605},"medium":{"n":104,"low":0.6795,"band":"medium","high":0.8397,"agree":80,"accuracy":0.7692}},"provider":"rule_based_v1+lex99e1195c7d6f","lexicon_id":"99e1195c7d6f","contract_published_at":"2026-10-23T12:25:29.022232+00:00","confidence_is_band":true,"confidence_is_probability":false,"decision_taxonomy":"two_way","decidable_fraction_two_way":0.8854,"decidable_fraction_two_way_low":0.8565,"decidable_fraction_two_way_high":0.9143,"decidable_fraction_three_way":0.8586,"decidable_fraction_three_way_low":0.8287,"decidable_fraction_three_way_high":0.8884,"decidable_population":5529,"validation_sample_size":438,"three_way_cost_fraction":0.0268,"three_way_cost_records":148,"decision_counts":{"automatable":230,"not_automatable":5299},"decision_split":{"automatable":{"count":230,"share":0.04159884246699222},"not_automatable":{"count":5299,"share":0.9584011575330078}},"diagnostic_work_type_counts":{"mixed":24,"physical":5275,"data_only":230}}}